Anthony Newarski

Anthony Newarski

Contact Details

Phone: 732-693-8042


The real estate market is constantly changing and I have a track record of navigating through the highs and lows. I got my start in 1989 investing in real estate. In the 25+ years since then, I have bought and sold investment properties, annual rentals and seasonal rental properties. I have done condo development work and worked with other investors and realtors flipping properties in Toronto, Mexico, the Washington DC area, and on the Jersey Shore. I received my real estate license in 2004 and joined the John C. Conover Agency in 2005. After years as an agent, I became part-owner of the company. When I was more active as an agent, I was awarded the Circle of Excellence Award by the Monmouth County Association of Realtors three times. When the housing market declined in 2009, I got Short Sale certification to help clients navigate the incredibly complex landscape some of them were entering. Shortly after that, I was asked to join the management team at Conover to help guide the company through the changing real estate market, which I did by focusing on unparalleled customer service and cutting edge marketing techniques. In 2014 I became the principal owner of the agency because I believe in the people, market, and opportunities here at the Jersey Shore. Honesty, innovation, financial savvy, and hands-on experience are cornerstones of my approach to business, and they’re part of the standard of excellence here. In 2018 we merged our company with Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Signature Properties to create a powerhouse real estate company and pull in the support we now have as a national brand.

Under my leadership, this company began the Vacation Rental Division and the Property Management Division to accompany our traditional Real Estate services. Our clients can depend on us to look after their homes and investments at every stage with as much care and consideration as we would give our own properties.

I have lived on the Jersey Shore for over 20 years and my local experience and relationships in the community benefit all of my buyers and sellers. My knowledge of all the available properties in both Monmouth and Ocean Counties, along with the relative risks and rewards of each venture, is unsurpassed. I focus on your needs and objectives, promise to listen intently and guarantee my customer service to be the best in the business. It is all about you, about getting you the best deal possible and always having your best interest at heart.

Click Here to View Anthony’s Recent Closed Listings


As first-time homebuyers, we had little knowledge and much anxiety about what the process would entail. Anthony made us feel comfortable by educating us and walking us through the whole thing. He was extremely professional, and we felt incredibly lucky to have a real estate agent who far exceeded our expectations. We will absolutely be using Anthony for any and all real estate ventures in the future.

— Allison Streck

Anthony was a pleasure to work with while I was selling my house. He was very knowledgable of the market and always responded to my phone calls and emails right away. He worked hard to find the right buyers and was able to successfully negotiate a fair price considering the bad economy. Anthony keeps a positive attitude even when the job gets challenging and tough. He is very friendly and professional, and I’d recommend him to anyone who seeks his services.

— R. Kavarsky

Anthony Newarski helped us purchase our condo in Asbury Park in 2008. The experience was nothing but joyful working with him. He is very helpful and knowledgeable about Asbury and answered all our questions and concerns asap. He was a pleasure to work with and we would recommand him to anyone and as a matter of fact we did to 3 other couples. Thanks again Anthony and good luck to you in the future.

–Maryann and Neil Wood

Anthony did a great job in managing our limited time by focusing on showing us houses that were of interest to us and in our price range. Once we found our dream house, Anthony was instrumental in guiding us through making a bid and winning our house in competition. His familiarity with the area was a great help in making the closing process with all the inspections and approvals very easy.

— R. Woertz

Anthony listened carefully to what we liked and didn’t like, and brought us to a house in a section of town we didn’t know existed. Our house is better than we had imagined when we set out on our search. He is very knowledgable about the area in general as well as specific properties. We couldn’t be happier with our home, the neighborhood, and everything Asbury Park has to offer.

— S. Merch

I was moving to the area from out of state and didn’t have much time for the search. I was lucky to come upon Anthony’s partner at an open house and I’ve been grateful ever since. He knows the area very well and was super helpful in guiding me. This was particularly important since I was also a first time home buyer. During the process of negotiating and closing, Anthony was always available, extremely knowledgeable and provided great expertise. Not only in Anthony a great realtor but he’s so much fun to be around and is a great person as well. I would recommend him in a heartbeat!

— Kristen